The last few months has seen a breathtaking rise in the price of Bitcoin. Starting around $15 at the beginning of the year, Bitcoin’s price went from round $200 to a peak of over $1,200 just during November. Then from early December BTC’s price began to falter, with a sudden drop and a low of $550 on the 18th: less than half its price just weeks before.
Commentary has been just as volatile, with some seeing BTC’s rising price as its explosion onto the scene and proof of its revolutionary potential. Others have scoffed, calling the whole thing a bubble inflated by overoptimistic geeks and people looking for a quick profit. Now that BTC’s price has come tumbling, should proponents of the crypto-currency be humbled and/or worried?
Recent rises and falls in Bitcoin’s price have reflected developments in China. In November Bitcoin exchange BTC China secured $5m investment from Lightspeed Venture Partners, and surpassed Mt Gox as the largest exchange in terms of trading volume. However, on the 5th December the People’s Bank of China announced that it does not consider Bitcoin a currency, barring banks & other financial institutions from dealing with it. Around this time Bitcoin’s price took a sharp downwards turn. Then, on Monday, the central bank banned 3rd-party payment companies from working with Bitcoin exchanges. This left Chinese exchanges unable to take deposits, and the price cfurther tumbled.
This is potentially bad news for entrepreneurs who want to see Bitcoin widely adopted, as well as for more ideological fans who consider Bitcoin’s strength its decentralised and stateless nature. Governments will never be able to stamp out Bitcoin completely, but making it as difficult as possible to use will hamper the objectives of both groups. The Mercatus Centre’s Bitcoin Primer explicitly urges policy makers to consider the technology morally neutral, warning against restricting its development and its use by non-criminal users. Whilst China cracks down on BTC its uptake in developing countries -particularly amongst the unbanked-is strong, and Denmark has just announced that it will not regulate Bitcoin or its exchange. China may well realise that it is missing a trick and relax its hostility.
Nevertheless, innovation around this problem will occur if it continues. Bitcoin is a global start-up project, with swathes of passionate and seriously techie fans.
Some take Bitcoin’s crash as proof that that it is an unstable and unsustainable folly- nothing more than a risky virtual commodity bet.
Certainly, Bitcoin’s volatility is an established fact, with its last big crash in April wiping out 80% of Bitcoin’s value over 6 days. Nevertheless, BTC has always recovered and increased in value. Indeed, since the 18th Bitcoin’s price has been creeping up yet again.
Calling bubbles is a funny thing, because both falls in price and continued rises offer ‘proof’ of the hypothesis. It is perhaps more accurate to say that Bitcoin is undergoing a long period of ‘price discovery’. A lot of purchases have been speculative or made out of curiosity, but as more users and ways to spend the currency emerge, so will a clearer and more stable idea of its price. Bitcoin’s shifting price isn’t even that much of an issue for those using it for purchases: vendors adjust their Bitcoin prices regularly to reflect the changing exchange rate. It is short-term investors and those calling Bitcoin the ‘new gold’ who should perhaps be more wary.
Others say that Bitcoin’s falling price reflects underlying concerns with the currency – such as issues with security and fraud, and exchanges’ ability to cope with demand. Some suggest these issues mean that Bitcoin will never be much more than a digital curiosity. But at the early stages of the computer and the internet few thought they would be so transformative, or could imagine how they would evolve. Bitcoin is certainty not ready for mainstream adoption or about to cause a central banking crisis, but that is zero reason to write it off. So much of how Bitcoin can and should operate is yet to be discovered, let alone decided. Despite all the recent attention it is still in its infancy, and growing pains and price shifts are an inevitable path of its development.
Even if Bitcoin’s price were to come crashing devastatingly down, the world’s first digital, decentralised ledger-based currency has created a new paradigm: a new way of thinking about money, transactions, anonymity and even our relationship with the state. Even some of Bitcoin’s biggest fans say it could one of the alternative, retweaked and ‘improved’ cyrpto-currencies which will really take off.
On which note- why care about the price of Bitcoin when you can be an early adopting millionaire of everyone’s favourite meme-cum-cryptocurrency, the shibe-tastic, very money Dogecoin! (wow)