Adam Smith Institute

Europe's favourite think tank website
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • Increase font size
What to do about local government finance Print E-mail
Written by Tom Clougherty   
Friday, 20 June 2008 06:03

Shadow Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles made the headlines last weekend with his pledge to cut council tax for 400,000 families. Apparently that's how many households are paying more tax than they should after being put in the wrong council tax band. The Tories say £400m in rebates could be given back to taxpayers.

Pickles also indicated that a Conservative government would reform the system of central government grants to local authorities, depoliticizing it and using an Australian-style formula to distribute the cash. In basic terms, the Australian system works as follows:

The revenue of the national goods and services tax (GST) is divided up between the states and territories on a per capita basis, adjusted by formula for different expenditure needs (based on socio-demographic and geographical factors), special purpose payments (based on need), and different revenue raising capacities (some states can raise a lot more revenue themselves).

Well, I suppose that's good in as far as it goes – the current system is riddled with party political bias – but Pickles' suggestions don't add up to the radical overhaul local government finance needs. The problem with any system that places so much emphasis on central government grants is that it undermines both the independence of local authorities and their accountability to residents. Councils become agents of the centre, eroding the rationale (more scope for competition and innovation in policy, and more direct accountability) for localism.

Of course, the difficulty of reforming local government finance is well known. As Mrs Thatcher found to her cost, such reforms always create winners and losers. The winners will be ungrateful, the losers will be angry, and central government will bear the brunt.

Perhaps the solution lies in taking a localist approach to the reform itself. Rather than driving through a particular reform from the centre, empower local authorities to come up with their own solutions. Give them a range of potential taxes to choose from, and let them strike the balance. If people didn’t like what their council came up with, they could always vote them out or move.

Comments (2)Add Comment
...
written by Christine Melsom, June 20, 2008
The only way to reform and then slim down local government is to take Central Government out of the equation. At the moment the Government has its sticky finger in 96% of local government spending (figure provided by the Treasurer of Hampshire). Employment in most councils continues to rise and with it the provision of the local government pension scheme. Many of these extra employees are as a result of Government interference.
The alternative is to fund centrally ordered services, education, social care land fill etc. to be funded by central Government and what is left paid for just as council tax. I understand that this could reduce council tax by about 75%.
I know that no Government is keen to put up income tax but this would be a case of swings and round-a-bouts. Everyone using the services would pay something towards paying for the services we all use,
The council tax payer, especially the low paid and pensioner, is collapsing under the weight of a tax pushed up continally by Government stealth.
Time for Land Value Tax
written by Mark Wadsworth, June 20, 2008
Wrong. They should wait until the bottom of the property/land price cycle; scrap all existing property-related taxes (Council Tax, Business Rates, Stamp Duty Land Tax, inheritance tax etc etc) and replace them with Land Value Tax, to be collected and spent by the relevant local authority. Conveniently, the total revenues from the above taxes are roughly equal to local authority spending excluding education (which would be replaced by education vouchers...) Continued page 94.

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.

busy
 

About the ASI

The Adam Smith Institute is the UK's leading innovator of free-market economic and social policies. Politically independent and non-profit, the Institute promotes its ideas through reports, briefings, events, media appearances, and its website and blog. For further information, click here.

rss180
facebook180
twitter180
youtube180

Join our email list

Email info@adamsmith.org if you would like to subscribe to our fortnightly e-bulletin.

Support the ASI

Enter Amount: