Political U-turns are good, not bad

U-turns are in the news, and are assumed to be a sign of weakness, an ‘embarrassing climb-down,’ and ‘a humiliating defeat.’ But there is a strong case to be made that U-turns in politics can be good.

 Politics happens in a fast-moving, complex world, and U-turns can reflect a willingness to adjust to new evidence or changing circumstances, or to incorporate expert advice or public feedback

For example, a government might reverse a harsh economic policy if it becomes clear it is harming vulnerable people. This shows they are listening and adapting.

 U-turns can be a sign that leaders are responsive to the will of the people. In a democracy, this is a core strength. Instead of berating their ‘weakness,’ one could say that politicians who change course after public protests, consultations, or elections are respecting democratic engagement.

 A U-turn often reflects the rare but valuable quality of political humility. It shows leaders are willing to admit they were wrong or were unaware of the full picture. It can signal a prioritization of public interest over personal pride

 Some of the best outcomes come after U-turns when policies are improved or refined and when harm is avoided or reversed. Trust can actually increase when a leader shows they are willing to change course.

The UK Government U-turned on free school meals in 2020. During the COVID pandemic, the UK government initially refused to extend free school meals during the summer holidays. And after a public campaign led by footballer Marcus Rashford and growing public pressure, the government reversed its decision.

 One could argue that this addressed child hunger at a critical time, showed responsiveness to public concern, and improved the government’s image on compassion and child welfare

President Barack Obama initially opposed same-sex marriage but later publicly changed his stance in 2012. His U-turn marked a cultural shift and helped legitimize the issue at a national level. It aligned the White House with growing public support for LGBT rights, and set the stage for the Supreme Court’s legalization of same-sex marriage in 2015. The U-turn reflected the evolving values of the nation, and demonstrated political courage.

Margaret Thatcher famously declared ‘You turn if you want to. The lady’s not for turning’ when she was pressured to U-turn on her free market, low tax agenda for growth. She was proved right by events, showing that why U-turns can be good, not all of them are.

Madsen Pirie