Bernard Levin spent many years warning of the Single Issue Fanatic. Someone who was so convinced of the importance of this one, single, thing that there was no acknowledgement of the fact that life is a series of trade offs. The recommendation was that no SIF should ever be given any power at all in our governance system. Simply because government never is about the one single issue. We live in a constrained world, everything is a trade off, there are always opportunity costs:
New housing is being blocked unless councillors agree to introduce green schemes such as Ulez and low-traffic neighbourhoods, in an approach that the environment watchdog is preparing to roll out across the country.
Natural England, which is already accused of blocking up to 145,000 homes, has commissioned a review of “mitigation measures” that could be used to limit emissions associated with new properties in the vicinity of more than 330 designated areas across the country.
Here we now have a statutory body which carries great power and is run by SIFs. That it’s currently run by Tony Juniper - why any Tory government made that appointment is a thing of wonder - is not the grand error. It’s that an organisation which will so obviously end up being run by fanatics over this single issue even exists that is the problem.
We have far too many of such as well, the CCC being only the most obvious of the others. The reason we can’t do anything is because the political system has these veto points and there is no system for being able to insist on consideration of the trade offs. The answer is to abolish them all.
No, all of them. We’re against much of the interference politics makes into lives, that’s true. But a useful insistence is that anyone who does wish to interfere politically has to stand for election. Whatever political power there is needs to be exercised by politicians we can get rid of - along with their plans - rather than this series of isolated power centres deliberately walled off from the body politic.
If there is to be politics then let there be politics, not bureaucracies accountable to no one.
Mr. Colville suggests that it’s the policies that are the problem. We insist that it’s allowing anyone to even have a policy.
Kill the quangos, stone dead.